The fill decides how an outdoor cushion feels and how long it holds its shape. Memory foam is soft and contouring, while polyurethane foam is springier. Listings also mention foam density, such as 28D or 35D, which is a firmness and durability marker.

This guide compares the two with listing examples. For picks, see our Best Outdoor Deep Seat Cushions and Best Replacement Foam for Outdoor Cushions.

The Two Fills

Memory foam

Memory foam contours to your body and feels softer. The MAGIC ELEPHANT listing describes a one-piece high-back pad filled with shredded memory foam, which is softer than a solid block. The idee-home listing describes layered memory foam in a thin chair pad.

MAGIC ELEPHANT Adirondack Chair Cushion, Memory Foam Outdoor Chair Cushion, Water-Repellent Thick High Back Patio Rocking Chair Pad Seat Cushion Replacement (Oxford Blue)

MAGIC ELEPHANT Adirondack Chair Cushion

Cushions
MAGIC ELEPHANT
amazon.com
In Stock
Updated: 6 days ago
Price as of Nov 12, 2026. We earn from qualifying purchases.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.

idee-home Outdoor Chair Cushions Set of 2, 17" x 17" D-Shaped | Thick Outdoor Seat Cushions Waterproof Patio Furniture with Ties Dining Pads

idee-home Outdoor Chair Cushions Set of 2

Cushions
idee-home
amazon.com
In Stock
Updated: 6 days ago
Price as of Nov 12, 2026. We earn from qualifying purchases.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.

Polyurethane foam

Polyurethane foam is firmer and springs back. The Arden Selections listing describes a seat cushion with 100% polyurethane foam shipped as a compressed roll. The Goodgoods listing describes 35D high-resilience foam, and the Zonamat listing describes 28D high-density foam.

Arden Selections ProFoam Performance Outdoor Seat Cushion 19 x 20, Lapis Blue

Arden Selections ProFoam Performance Outdoor Seat

Cushions
Arden Selections
amazon.com
In Stock
Updated: 6 days ago
Price as of Nov 12, 2026. We earn from qualifying purchases.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.

Goodgoods 24x28 Outdoor Deep Seat Cushions 2-Pack, 35D Foam, Beige | 35D High-Resilience Foam, Fade-Resistant for 1000+ Hours, Water-Resistant for Outdoor Sofa Chairs

Goodgoods 24x28 Outdoor Deep Seat Cushions 2-Pack

Cushions
Goodgoods
amazon.com
In Stock
Updated: 6 days ago
Price as of Nov 12, 2026. We earn from qualifying purchases.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.

Zonamat 48 x 18 x 3 Bench Cushion Review: Best Washable

Zonamat 48 x 18 x 3 Bench Cushion Review

Cushions
Zonamat
amazon.com
In Stock
Updated: 6 days ago
Price as of Nov 12, 2026. We earn from qualifying purchases.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.

How They Differ

Memory foamPolyurethane foam
FeelSoft, contouringFirmer, springy
SupportDistributes weight, can sinkHolds shape and lifts back
WarmthCan hold heatUsually cooler
WeightOften heavierOften lighter
Typical useSoft chair and swing padsSeat cushions that see daily use

Fill, thickness and fabric claims in listings are the makers' own, and comfort is personal. Density ratings such as 28D or 35D are the makers' labels and are not directly comparable between brands.

Which Fits You

  • Soft, relaxed seating: memory foam
  • Firm seating that keeps its height: polyurethane foam
  • Frequent use in a hot climate: lean toward polyurethane

Care for Both

Outdoor cushions are not made for storms. Bring them in or cover them during heavy rain, snow or long damp spells, let them dry fully before storing, and follow the care label. Water-resistant and fade-resistant claims come from the maker and have limits. Foam that stays wet can develop mildew, so dry cushions fully.

FAQ

Which lasts longer?

Higher-density foam usually holds shape longer, but the cover and care matter as much.

Is memory foam good outdoors?

It can be, in sheltered spots. It holds moisture and heat more than polyurethane.

What does 35D mean?

A density marker some makers use. Compare it within a brand, not across brands.

Can I replace the foam in a cushion?

Often yes, if the cover is removable. See our replacement foam guide.

Best lists: Best Outdoor Bench Cushions Under $30, Best Outdoor Deep Seat Cushions Under $50. Reviews: MAGIC ELEPHANT Memory Foam Adirondack Chair Cushion Review, idee-home 17 x 17 D-Shaped Outdoor Chair Cushions Set of 2 Review, Arden Selections ProFoam 19 x 20 Outdoor Seat Cushion Review, Goodgoods 24 x 28 Outdoor Deep Seat Cushions 2-Pack Review, Zonamat 48 x 18 Waterproof Outdoor Bench Cushion Review. More comparisons: Deep Seat vs Standard Seat Outdoor Cushions.

The Bottom Line

Choose memory foam for a soft pad and polyurethane foam for firm support. Fill, thickness and fabric claims in listings are the makers' own, and comfort is personal.

Measure first, and store cushions in bad weather.